Skip to main content
The National Cipher Challenge

Struggling

Viewing 4 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • #164026
      organ0rt1
      Participant

      Hi, would I be able to share my code and result with someone because I am really stuck what to do next?

    • #164055
      harry
      Keymaster

      The struggle is all part of it! Please do feel free to ask questions here, we can always delay them if we think they are giving too much away, or hold back answers you get for the same reason. Harry]

    • #164177
      Puzzling_Pelican
      Participant

      @organ0rt1
      There are a bunch of alumni and other participants in the forum that would be happy to help with any questions, so long as it doesn’t give away too much information about ongoing challenges.

      Trying to guess what your question might be, here is some advice:

      Bug in the code?
      Try write down exactly what you want the code to do (yes, on paper). Then write down step by step what the code needs to do to achieve that, run that through an example. Then run the same example through your code using a debugger (or a bunch of print statements if you are lazy) and see where they diverge. The moment your code does anything different than what you expected like crashing or an off by one, walk back and find exactly where it starts and what caused it. This should hopefully give you an idea of where the bug is. Fix it and then repeat for the two new bugs that each fix inevitably creates.

      Trying to work out how to implement or break a cipher with code?
      One of the alumni have started putting together as series of guides trying to introduce this. You can find the first part here: https://www.cipherchallenge.org/its-almost-like-christmas-is-here-already/ The series might eventually cover the cipher you are looking at currently, and if not, it will build up the knowledge of how to approach it.

    • #166181
      qwertyuiop
      Participant

      I’m really stuck on part A of chapter 5. Can anyone help

      • #166185
        harry
        Keymaster

        Maybe tomorrow? If anyone has a good hint post it here and we will see what we can post, but, for now, try not to give the whole game away.

      • #166198
        Robb27
        Participant

        @qwertyuiop For 5A you have seen this type of cipher before recently. If you look at the first 10 or so characters you might see something ???

      • #166199
        Intriguing_Iguana1234
        Participant

        After frequency analysis, we know its still a transposition cipher. A good way to work out what a simple transposition cipher is by looking for rare letters in key words. The title gives a clue…

      • #166239
        MI6_And_A_Half
        Participant

        if u go to the case files, u can notice a pattern, its a letter so its starts with my dear :), good luck, hope u crack the cipher

      • #166358
        giii
        Participant

        Try looking at earlier challenges. You should see some links between them.

    • #166186
      f6exb_the_frenchy
      Participant

      The first three groups sparked a little light in my mind.

Viewing 4 reply threads
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
Report a problem